Hello dear
Welcome To Timmy's Pizza & BBQ Garrett
Timmy's Pizza & BBQ Garrett, located at 105 N Randolph St, Garrett, IN, is a culinary gem known for its gourmet offerings. The heartfelt reviews speak volumes about the exquisite Chicago-style pizza, renowned for its generous portions and bold flavors. Customers rave about Tim's dedication and the friendly staff, who create a welcoming environment. The BBQ also garners high praise, with smoked wings that deliver just the right spice. Diners appreciate Timmy's commitment to quality, both in food and service. Whether you're craving pizza or barbecue, Timmy's delivers an exceptional dining experience worth repeating.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
One Topping Pizza
Pulled Chicken By The Pound
Ham & Cheese Sub
Chicken Club Sandwich
About
Timmy's Pizza & BBQ Garrett
Welcome to Timmy's Pizza & BBQ Garrett, a hidden gem located in the heart of Garrett, Indiana. From the first bite to the last, this establishment serves up delicious gourmet pizza paired with irresistible barbecue, all crafted with passion and care. Timmy's, situated at 105 N Randolph St, has quickly gained a loyal following thanks to its commitment to quality and flavor.
Customers rave about the extensive pizza options, including the iconic Chicago-style pizza, which has been notably described as a feast fit for a family of four. According to Shawn Payton, the Chicago-style pizza is “everything we were hoping for and so much more.” The rich layers of cheese, sauce, and toppings provide an unforgettable experience. Meanwhile, the pan and thin crust varieties have left patrons like Charles Hill unable to choose a favorite, praising the dedication of the owner, Donald, who takes immense pride in his unique pizza shop.
Not just limited to pizza, Timmy's BBQ offerings also deserve a mention. Customers have shared praises of the smoked chicken wings, which boast an exceptional flavor profile, making every bite a smoky delight. Michael Zumbaugh highlights how the friendly staff ensures your meal is ready promptly, enhancing the entire dining experience. With a clean and cozy ambiance, the dining room invites customers to relish their meals in comfort.
Exceptional service is also a cornerstone of Timmy's reputation. As evidenced by Chad Neilands, when an issue arose with a previous order, the management’s prompt and accommodating response demonstrated their commitment to customer satisfaction. This attention to detail is truly a rarity and speaks volumes about their dedication.
For those seeking an unforgettable meal in Garrett, Timmy's Pizza & BBQ is a must-visit. The return of Timmy, along with his cherished recipes, has reinvigorated this local favorite, garnering positive feedback from patrons like Brian Krus. Whether you’re craving pizza or barbecue, Timmy’s stands ready to deliver an exceptional culinary experience. Give them a call at +1 260-357-6666 and prepare to indulge in a delightful feast.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Excellent gourmet pizza and barbecue!!! Amazing experience Tim and staff were great! Chicago style pizza was everything we were hoping for and so much more! Wings had an amazing smoked favor and the hot was just right! Highly recommended. ”
“ Now I've had the Chicago style, the Pan Crust and the Thin Crust, I can't seem to pick a favorite one, they're all great! The owner Donald is awesome, he takes pride in this unique pizza shop. Great staff that treats you with smiles and respect! Next time I've got to try the Bar B Q! I've heard it's great too! ”
“ The Chicago Style is huge! A medium could probably feed a family of 4. The guy at the counter was friendly and my order was ready when I walked in. The dining room is small but it looks clean and all the signs are cool. ”
“ I haven’t even had a chance to try the food. All I know is I called up and explained my concern that the ribs that I got were too rubbery! The manager at the time not sure if he’s the owner or what his name was Tim. He offered to let me get a new full slab of ribs tomorrow free of charge to make up for the ribs that I got today! Excellent service great care for the customer and great pride in the business! 5 stars just for that! That’s rare! ”
“ I had to re-review since timmy bought back his business and all the delicious recipes and ingredients. Had a deluxe thin crust, damn it was good. Great to have things done the way they're supposed to be at this local favorite. Pizza was outstanding! ”
“ I only ate their once before they temporarily closed and remodeled their company. But I LOVED and I mean LOVED the pizza there. I was very impressed with my order. And I wouldn’t mind one bit to eat there again! Great place for small-town pizza ”
“ Best pizza, best smoked wings, best crazy dough, best sausage rolls. Hardest working & down to earth owners you’ll ever meet! Love all their food! Catch them on the road as well at the festivals too! You won’t be disappointed!! ”
“ Owners wife makes her own mango sauce that is so good. All of their menu options are good. Wait staff is nice. Plenty of food for the price. Train wreck pizza is our favorite. Clean restaurant. ”